Skip to content

PM Competency Matrix

Diagnostic tool for product management levels. Pick a level, check the behaviors, score.


TL;DR

  • 20 skills, 5 levels, 79 behaviors — APM through Principal PM
  • ★ = mandatory — PM's level = MIN(mandatory level, overall level). No exceptions
  • Behaviors are cumulative — Senior PM ticks everything APM and PM tick, plus Senior-level behaviors
  • Per-level sections — Go to the level you're evaluating, check mandatory first, then the rest
  • Verify column — Every behavior tagged: A (artifact), P (peer feedback), S (self-reported)
  • 80% threshold — Tick ≥ 80% of a level's behaviors to pass. Not perfection — pattern

How to Use This

Self-Assessment First, Manager Review After

  1. PM self-scores. Fill in ✓/✗ for each behavior. Every ✓ needs a concrete example — PRD link, doc, metric, customer quote, one line
  2. Manager reviews. Confirm or adjust. Flag disagreements (✓ → ✗ or ✗ → ✓)
  3. 15-min sync. Discuss disagreements only. Skip what matches

This scales — manager spends 5-10 min reviewing instead of 15-20 min scoring from scratch. Disagreements become the conversation: "You ticked this but I don't see evidence" is more productive than "here's my score."

Scoring Steps

  1. Pick the level you're evaluating (e.g. "Is this person Senior PM?")
  2. Check mandatory ★ skills first. If they don't pass mandatory at that level, stop. They're not that level
  3. Check remaining skills. Score each behavior ✓ or ✗
  4. Count. ≥ 80% of that level's behaviors = pass
  5. Check cumulative. They must also pass all levels below. A Senior PM must pass APM and PM too
  6. Final level = MIN(mandatory level, overall level)

Behaviors are cumulative. A Senior PM should demonstrate all APM, PM, AND Senior PM behaviors. If a behavior starts at PM, it's expected at Senior PM, Lead PM, and Principal PM too.


The Mandatory Rule (★)

Five skills are mandatory: Clear Communication, Problem Discovery, Data & Decisions, Outcome Ownership, Cross-Functional Collaboration.

Mechanic: PM's level = MIN(mandatory level, overall level).

Worked example:

Alice scores Senior PM on overall behaviors (82% of Senior PM behaviors ticked). But on mandatory ★ skills alone, she only passes PM (75% of Senior PM mandatory behaviors).

Alice's level: PM. Not Senior PM. The mandatory score caps her.

Why: A Lead PM who can't discover real problems or make data-driven decisions is a liability, not a multiplier. Mandatory skills are the behaviors that make every other skill effective. Product sense without communication, discovery, data fluency, ownership, and collaboration creates isolated impact that doesn't scale.


How to Verify Behaviors

Every behavior has a Verify tag. Use it to know where to look for evidence.

TagMeaningWhere to look
A (Artifact)Leaves a trailPRDs, specs, roadmaps, strategy docs, research reports, dashboards, launch plans, retrospectives, OKR reviews
P (Peer)Requires feedback from others360 reviews, peer interviews, cross-team feedback, skip-level 1:1s, eng/design partner feedback
S (Self)Self-reported, inferred over timeStrategic thinking, relationship quality, long-term planning patterns, market intuition

Rule of thumb: If a PM scores high on A and S but low on P, collect more peer feedback before finalizing. Artifacts show what someone shipped. Peers show how they shipped it.


Skill Categories

CategorySkills
Core (★ mandatory)Clear Communication, Problem Discovery, Data & Decisions, Outcome Ownership, Cross-Functional Collaboration
Product CraftUser Research, Prioritization, Spec Writing, Roadmap Planning, Product Sense, Experimentation
Business & TechnicalBusiness Acumen, Technical Fluency, Market Awareness, Go-to-Market
Leadership & InfluenceStakeholder Management, Mentoring, Strategic Thinking, Hiring & Talent, Org Impact

Terminology

Terms used in the behaviors below. Skim now, reference later.

TermWhat it means
PRDProduct Requirements Document. Describes the what and why of a feature: problem, solution, requirements, success metrics, edge cases. Engineers and designers build from this
RICEReach, Impact, Confidence, Effort. Prioritization framework. Score = (Reach × Impact × Confidence) / Effort. Forces explicit trade-offs instead of gut feel
OKRObjectives and Key Results. Goal-setting framework. Objective = qualitative direction ("Improve onboarding"). Key Results = measurable outcomes ("Increase activation from 60% to 75%")
NPSNet Promoter Score. "How likely are you to recommend us?" on 0-10 scale. Promoters (9-10) minus Detractors (0-6) = NPS. Range: -100 to +100
CSATCustomer Satisfaction Score. "How satisfied are you?" on 1-5 scale. Percentage of 4s and 5s. Measures specific interactions, not overall loyalty
CACCustomer Acquisition Cost. Total sales + marketing spend / new customers acquired. "It costs us $150 to get a new customer"
LTVLifetime Value (also CLV). Revenue a customer generates over their entire relationship. LTV = ARPU × Gross Margin × Average Lifespan. LTV/CAC > 3 is healthy
ARRAnnual Recurring Revenue. Total yearly value of all active subscriptions. The north star metric for SaaS. MRR × 12 = ARR
GTMGo-to-Market. Strategy for launching a product: who to sell to, how to reach them, what to charge, how to enable sales. Pricing + positioning + channels + enablement
A/B testShow version A to 50% of users, version B to 50%. Measure which performs better. Data, not opinions
Cohort analysisGroup users by when they signed up (or another event). Compare behavior across cohorts. "January cohort retains at 40%, March cohort at 55% — what changed?"
FunnelSequence of steps users take toward a goal. Sign up → Activate → Convert → Retain. Measure drop-off at each step to find the biggest lever
North Star metricThe single metric that best captures the value you deliver to customers. Airbnb: nights booked. Slack: messages sent. Not revenue — value delivered
Unit economicsRevenue and costs per customer or transaction. "We make $50/customer but spend $30 to acquire and $15 to serve them. $5 profit per unit"
P&LProfit and Loss statement. Revenue minus costs = profit. "Own the P&L" = accountable for both revenue and expenses
Product-market fitWhen customers want your product enough to pay for it, tell others, and come back. Leading indicators: retention curves flatten, NPS > 40, organic growth
DiscoveryResearch phase before building. Understand the problem, validate solutions, reduce risk. Interviews + data + prototypes. Build confidence that you're solving the right problem
Feature flagToggle that enables/disables a feature without deploying new code. Ship dark, enable for 5% of users, then 100%

APM (Level 1) — 12 behaviors

Entry level. Ships reliably, learns product craft, asks for help.

Mandatory Skills ★

SkillBehaviorVerify
Clear CommunicationFlags blockers same day, not next dayA
Clear CommunicationCommunicates proactively — updates without prompting, answers directlyP
Problem Discovery ★Talks to users weekly. Documents pain points, not just feature requestsA
Data & Decisions ★Uses data to support decisions. Pulls basic metrics from dashboardsA
Outcome Ownership ★Follows features through launch. Checks adoption metrics within first weekA
Cross-Functional Collaboration ★Works with engineering and design daily without creating bottlenecksP
Cross-Functional Collaboration ★Asks for help within 30 min of being stuck on a cross-team dependencyP

Product Craft

SkillBehaviorVerify
User ResearchConducts structured user interviews using a script. Summarizes findingsA
Spec WritingWrites clear specs with user stories, acceptance criteria, and edge casesA
Product SenseExplains what problem the feature solves and who it's forP

Business & Technical

SkillBehaviorVerify
Technical FluencyUnderstands system architecture enough to scope work with engineersP

Leadership & Influence

SkillBehaviorVerify
Stakeholder ManagementKeeps stakeholders informed with weekly status updatesA

PM (Level 2) — 18 behaviors

Must also meet APM. Owns features end-to-end, validates problems before building, measures outcomes.

Mandatory Skills ★

SkillBehaviorVerify
Clear CommunicationCommunicates risks proactively with options, not just problemsA
Clear CommunicationWritten updates use specifics — numbers, dates, owners, not vague estimatesA
Problem Discovery ★Identifies root problems vs. symptoms. Reframes requests into underlying needsA
Problem Discovery ★Validates problems before solutioning. Kills features that don't solve real painA
Data & Decisions ★Defines success metrics before building. Tracks leading and lagging indicatorsA
Data & Decisions ★Runs basic analyses (funnels, cohorts, retention curves) without analyst supportA
Outcome Ownership ★Owns features end-to-end: discovery, spec, ship, measure adoption, iterateA
Outcome Ownership ★Writes launch retrospectives — what worked, what didn't, what to do differentlyA
Cross-Functional Collaboration ★Ships work that requires engineering, design, and stakeholder input without delaysP

Product Craft

SkillBehaviorVerify
User ResearchTriangulates research: combines qualitative (interviews) with quantitative (analytics)A
PrioritizationUses a framework (RICE, ICE, or similar) and explains trade-offs to stakeholdersA
Spec WritingSpecs include edge cases, out-of-scope, and technical constraints. Engineers can build without ambiguityA
Roadmap PlanningMaintains a quarterly roadmap. Communicates changes with rationaleA
Product SensePushes back on stakeholder requests with a simpler alternative that solves the core problemP

Business & Technical

SkillBehaviorVerify
Technical FluencyScopes features accurately with engineering. Understands trade-offs between speed and qualityP
Market AwarenessMonitors competitors. Knows their strengths and weaknesses relative to your productA

Leadership & Influence

SkillBehaviorVerify
Stakeholder ManagementManages expectations proactively. Says no with rationale and alternativesP
MentoringOnboards new PMs — shares templates, pairs on first spec, checks in weeklyP

Senior PM (Level 3) — 21 behaviors

Must also meet APM and PM. Drives business impact, leads cross-team work, mentors others.

Mandatory Skills ★

SkillBehaviorVerify
Clear CommunicationDrives alignment via PRDs and strategy docs that teams can execute independentlyA
Clear CommunicationPresents product strategy to non-technical stakeholders and execsP
Problem Discovery ★Maps problem spaces systematically. Identifies opportunities others missA
Data & Decisions ★Defines product metrics frameworks. Sets team-level OKRs that connect to business outcomesA
Outcome Ownership ★Owns product area outcomes. Investigates metric drops before being askedA
Cross-Functional Collaboration ★Drives cross-team initiatives. Resolves priority conflicts across teamsP

Product Craft

SkillBehaviorVerify
User ResearchDesigns research programs. Builds continuous feedback loops (NPS, advisory boards, CSAT)A
PrioritizationMakes explicit trade-offs between short-term revenue and long-term platform investmentA
Spec WritingWrites vision specs that inspire the team and set direction for multiple quartersA
Roadmap PlanningPlans 2-3 quarters ahead. Balances new features, tech debt, and growth initiativesA
Product SenseConnects product decisions to business outcomes ("This integration unblocks $200K ARR")A
ExperimentationDesigns A/B tests with clear hypotheses, sample sizes, and success criteriaA

Business & Technical

SkillBehaviorVerify
Business AcumenUnderstands unit economics (CAC, LTV, payback period). Sizes opportunities in revenue termsA
Technical FluencyPartners with engineering to make build/buy/integrate decisions with clear trade-offs documentedA
Market AwarenessPositions product against competitors. Identifies gaps and defensible advantagesA
Go-to-MarketPartners with marketing/sales on launch plans. Defines messaging, segments, and enablementA

Leadership & Influence

SkillBehaviorVerify
Stakeholder ManagementAligns stakeholders with competing priorities. Escalates with proposals, not complaintsP
MentoringMentors 1-2 junior PMs toward next level. People you mentor get promotedP
Strategic ThinkingThinks 2-3 quarters ahead. Proposes where to invest and where to sunsetS
Hiring & TalentInterviews PM candidates. Gives clear hire/no-hire with evidenceA
Org ImpactShips products that move company metrics. Other teams benefit from your workA

Lead PM (Level 4) — 16 behaviors

Must also meet APM, PM, and Senior PM. Multiplies the product org, sets product direction, influences without authority.

Mandatory Skills ★

SkillBehaviorVerify
Clear CommunicationInfluences org-wide decisions through written proposals and strategy docsA
Problem Discovery ★Defines problem spaces across product lines. Identifies the highest-leverage problems for the companyA
Data & Decisions ★Sets org-wide product metrics. Defines what "good" looks like across all product areasA
Outcome Ownership ★Owns multi-product outcomes: tracks portfolio health (adoption, revenue, retention) and reallocates investment when metrics slipA
Cross-Functional Collaboration ★Influences without authority. Creates decision forums (product council, roadmap review)P

Product Craft

SkillBehaviorVerify
PrioritizationAllocates resources across product areas based on business impact and strategic fitA
Roadmap PlanningOwns multi-team roadmap. Coordinates dependencies across product areasA
Product SenseIdentifies whitespace opportunities that become new product lines or revenue streamsS
ExperimentationBuilds experimentation culture. Teams run tests by default, not by exceptionA

Business & Technical

SkillBehaviorVerify
Business AcumenOwns P&L or revenue targets for product area. Makes investment cases with financial modelsA
Technical FluencySets technical direction with engineering leaders. Defines platform strategyA
Go-to-MarketDefines GTM strategy across product portfolio. Coordinates pricing, packaging, and channel strategyA

Leadership & Influence

SkillBehaviorVerify
MentoringDevelops senior PMs into leads. Scales PM craft through programs, frameworks, and ritualsP
Strategic ThinkingOwns 1-year product roadmap. Ships features while building strategic moats quarter over quarterA
Hiring & TalentDesigns PM interview process. Defines hiring bar. Attracts talent through reputationA
Org ImpactMakes 10+ people across teams more effective. Multiplies the product orgP

Principal PM (Level 5) — 12 behaviors

Must also meet APM, PM, Senior PM, and Lead PM. Shapes company direction, defines how product works.

Mandatory Skills ★

SkillBehaviorVerify
Clear CommunicationRepresents product to board/execs. Shapes company narrativeP
Problem Discovery ★Identifies transformative opportunities — new markets, new business models, or category-defining movesS
Data & Decisions ★Defines company-wide success metrics. Business reviews run on frameworks you builtA
Outcome Ownership ★Owns company-level product outcomes. Product metrics trend in the right direction quarter over quarterA
Cross-Functional Collaboration ★Partners with exec team on product investment decisionsP

Product Craft

SkillBehaviorVerify
Product SenseTechnology and product decisions you drive open revenue streams or markets the company didn't have beforeA
ExperimentationCompany-wide experimentation platform and culture. Teams are data-driven by defaultA

Business & Technical

SkillBehaviorVerify
Business AcumenShapes business model and pricing strategy at company levelA
Market AwarenessAnticipates market shifts 1-2 years ahead. Positions the company before competitors reactS

Leadership & Influence

SkillBehaviorVerify
MentoringDevelops future product leaders. Creates PM leadership pipelineP
Strategic ThinkingDefines 2-3 year product vision. Company strategy reflects your product directionA
Org ImpactProduct practices you introduced are how the company defaults to workingP

Split Levels

When someone is Lead PM at X but Senior PM at Y, the split is the diagnostic — not the number.

Rule: Official level = MIN(mandatory level, overall level). But the split tells you where to invest.

Common Patterns

PatternWhat it meansAction
Lead product craft / Senior leadershipStrong builder, not yet a multiplierGrowth plan for mentoring, stakeholder management, org influence
Senior everything / PM communicationProduct skills blocked by communication gapFocus on Clear Communication for one quarter. Write strategy docs, present to execs
Senior overall / PM mandatoryCapable PM held back by core skill gapIdentify which mandatory skill is lagging. Targeted improvement plan
Lead business / Senior product craftStrong business instinct, discovery and experimentation gapsPair with strong user researcher. Lead a discovery sprint end-to-end

Worked Example

Dave scores Lead PM on product craft (85% of Lead PM behaviors ticked) and Lead PM on leadership & influence (82%). But on mandatory ★ skills, he only passes Senior PM (78% of Lead PM mandatory behaviors — below 80%).

Dave's level: Senior PM. His mandatory score caps him at Senior PM even though his overall skills are Lead PM-level.

The split tells the story: Dave needs to close the gap on 1-2 mandatory Lead PM behaviors. His manager reviews the specific behaviors he's missing — turns out he hasn't created decision forums (Cross-Functional Collaboration ★) or defined org-wide product metrics (Data & Decisions ★). Those become his next-quarter goals.


Common Mistakes

MistakeFix
Scoring potential, not demonstrated behaviorScore last 2 quarters. No credit for "could"
Ignoring mandatory because product craft is strongRun mandatory check first. If it fails, stop
Only scoring Artifact behaviorsCollect peer feedback quarterly. Skip-level 1:1s reveal what artifacts don't
One good quarter = level upRequire 2-3 quarters sustained. One quarter is a spike
Averaging across skillsLook at the split. An average hides the gap
Checklist mentalityEvery ✓ needs a concrete example: "When? What outcome?"
Evaluating Lead+ without cross-team inputLead+ is org-wide. Get input from 3+ teams
"Ships features" vs "multiplies others"If only personal output is high, that's Senior PM, not Lead PM
Self-assessment over-scoringRequire a concrete example per ✓ — PRD link, doc, metric. "When? What outcome?" kills inflation
Self-assessment under-scoringCross-check with peer feedback, especially P-tagged behaviors. Humble PMs miss their own impact

Spreadsheet Template

Make a copy of the spreadsheet template — add PM names as columns.

Layout

Skill | Category | Mandatory | Behavior | Level | Alice | Bob | ...
  • Category: Core, Product Craft, Business & Technical, or Leadership & Influence
  • Mandatory: ★ or blank
  • Level: 1-5 (the level where this behavior starts)
  • Each PM cell: ✓ if demonstrated, blank if not

Tagging rows

Add a Level column to each behavior row:

LevelValueMeans
APM1Behavior starts at APM
PM2Behavior starts at PM
Senior PM3Behavior starts at Senior PM
Lead PM4Behavior starts at Lead PM
Principal PM5Behavior starts at Principal PM

Formulas (Google Sheets / Excel)

Assume: Column C = Mandatory (★ or blank), Column D = Level (1-5), Column E onward = PM scores.

Count ticked behaviors per level (summary rows at bottom):

APM ticked:          =COUNTIFS($D:$D,1,E:E,"✓")
APM total:           =COUNTIF($D:$D,1)
PM ticked:           =COUNTIFS($D:$D,2,E:E,"✓")
PM total:            =COUNTIF($D:$D,2)
Senior PM ticked:    =COUNTIFS($D:$D,3,E:E,"✓")
Senior PM total:     =COUNTIF($D:$D,3)
Lead PM ticked:      =COUNTIFS($D:$D,4,E:E,"✓")
Lead PM total:       =COUNTIF($D:$D,4)
Principal PM ticked: =COUNTIFS($D:$D,5,E:E,"✓")
Principal PM total:  =COUNTIF($D:$D,5)

Overall level (≥ 80% threshold):

=IF(AND(E_APM_ticked/E_APM_total>=0.8, E_PM_ticked/E_PM_total>=0.8, E_SeniorPM_ticked/E_SeniorPM_total>=0.8, E_LeadPM_ticked/E_LeadPM_total>=0.8, E_PrincipalPM_ticked/E_PrincipalPM_total>=0.8),"Principal PM", IF(AND(E_APM_ticked/E_APM_total>=0.8, E_PM_ticked/E_PM_total>=0.8, E_SeniorPM_ticked/E_SeniorPM_total>=0.8, E_LeadPM_ticked/E_LeadPM_total>=0.8),"Lead PM", IF(AND(E_APM_ticked/E_APM_total>=0.8, E_PM_ticked/E_PM_total>=0.8, E_SeniorPM_ticked/E_SeniorPM_total>=0.8),"Senior PM", IF(AND(E_APM_ticked/E_APM_total>=0.8, E_PM_ticked/E_PM_total>=0.8),"PM", IF(E_APM_ticked/E_APM_total>=0.8,"APM","Below APM")))))

Mandatory level (★ rows only):

=IF(AND(COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,2,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,2)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,3,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,3)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,4,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,4)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,5,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,5)>=0.8),"Principal PM", IF(AND(COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,2,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,2)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,3,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,3)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,4,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,4)>=0.8),"Lead PM", IF(AND(COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,2,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,2)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,3,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,3)>=0.8),"Senior PM", IF(AND(COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1)>=0.8, COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,2,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,2)>=0.8),"PM", IF(COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1,E:E,"✓")/COUNTIFS($C:$C,"★",$D:$D,1)>=0.8,"APM","Below APM")))))

Final level = MIN(mandatory level, overall level).

Use a lookup: assign numeric values (APM=1, PM=2, etc.), take the MIN, convert back.

Why 80%: Nobody ticks every box. 80% means they consistently demonstrate the level's behaviors — not perfection, but pattern.

Example

SkillMandatoryBehaviorLevelAliceBob
Clear CommFlags blockers same day1
Clear CommWritten updates use specifics2
Clear CommDrives alignment via PRDs3
Problem DiscoveryTalks to users weekly1
Problem DiscoveryMaps problem spaces systematically3
User ResearchTriangulates qual + quant2
...............
Summary
APM %100%100%
PM %95%85%
Senior PM %82%40%
Lead PM %20%0%
Overall LevelSenior PMPM
Mandatory LevelSenior PMPM
Final LevelSenior PMPM

Alice — ticks ≥ 80% at APM, PM, and Senior PM. Falls off at Lead PM (20%). Mandatory level also Senior PM. Final: Senior PM.

Bob — ticks ≥ 80% at APM and PM. Only 40% of Senior PM behaviors. Final: PM. Growth areas: strategy docs, problem space mapping, experimentation, cross-team leadership.


Level Check Summary

LevelThresholdIn one sentence
APM≥ 80% of APM behaviorsShips reliably, learns product craft, asks for help
PM≥ 80% of APM + PM behaviorsOwns features end-to-end, validates problems, measures outcomes
Senior PM≥ 80% of APM + PM + Senior PM behaviorsDrives business impact, leads cross-team work, mentors others
Lead PM≥ 80% of APM + PM + Senior PM + Lead PM behaviorsMultiplies the product org, sets product direction, influences without authority
Principal PM≥ 80% of all behaviorsShapes company direction, defines how product works

The rule: You're at a level when you consistently tick ≥ 80% of that level's behaviors AND all levels below it. Not your best week — your average quarter. Mandatory ★ skills cap the level.


References